gnomonlearn
Docs/Adopted QA and catalog source alignment

Adopted QA and catalog source alignment

Versioned draft snapshot

RFCs, reference catalogs, and evidence reflect Spec 3b2e3e7a114fb826b1445d39a48756b8fff629cd. Counts and pending/status notes belong to that snapshot. Read the dated project update for later progress.

Source repositories are private during staging. Links marked “repository access required” need access to the linked repository.

This is a trace and gap record from the pinned draft specification. It does not establish proof or implementation conformance.

Canonical spec was locally fast-forwarded from 68496d532fbc88e061c187f188a3eedd50e5c4ba to b0d544c6a3f4fb7fa6a93489f1fb8dce1f79ceb8. This directory preserves the source-safe evidence for those three routine corrections and separately records that local adoption. No native gate was rerun and no publication occurred.

Preserved observations

historical/ is the original 125-file capsule copied byte/mode-identically, plus the unchanged historical metadata verifier. Its original scopes, absolute argv/paths and preadoption statements remain verbatim. The original working capsule and formal evidence are unchanged. The observed source changes are in historical/source.patch; the detailed source/acceptance account is in historical/receipts/README.md.

The preserved gates report 303 QA questions, 120 valid section citations, 742 unchanged diagnostic entries and 129 catalog-hash-only projection rebindings. The 55-module native workflow compiles/emits RFC catalog data: one M03225 guidance literal changed from error to warning; the other 56 Turtle files and all reference catalogs remained unchanged. No authored proof or runtime conformance acceptance is inferred. The inconsistent external pin and strict release blockers remain active.

Portability and adoption record

adoption.textproto/adoption.pb use adoption.proto. They distinguish the local source adoption from historical preadoption execution. Explicit aliases map every hashed absolute input/output/log reference to a relative preserved copy. Supplemental files in retained-inputs/ are exact captured historical bytes, verified against the original receipt; they are not replacement sources. Historical argv is provenance and is not rewritten into runnable portable commands. Full POSIX modes describe the actual copy operation; Git preserves executable bits and checkout umasks can change other permission bits.

Run python3 verify.py from any location to verify the local copy, aliases and protobuf pairs. This metadata-only verifier reads no original workspace path and runs no Git, Lean, Bazel, Cargo or product gate.

The copied historical/preadoption-verifier.py assumes canonical HEAD 68496d5. That assertion no longer applies after local adoption at b0d544c6a. It remains unchanged historical source and was not rerun to produce an expected failure or a new passing result. Use the new portable verifier for this evidence copy.

Historical generated/generation.pb binds source b0d544c6a and its tracked tree. It does not cover the forthcoming commit adding this evidence directory. A later preview/package requires fresh generation at its actual source pin. No formal pin, theorem, premise, diagnostic identity/severity allocation, review verdict or unresolved feature answer was changed by this preservation step.