RFCs, reference catalogs, and evidence reflect Spec 3b2e3e7a114fb826b1445d39a48756b8fff629cd. Counts and pending/status notes belong to that snapshot. Read the dated project update for later progress.
Source repositories are private during staging. Links marked “repository access required” need access to the linked repository.
This is a trace and gap record from the pinned draft specification. It does not establish proof or implementation conformance.
The field names and AX identifiers below come from the pinned external Spec.Kernel at commit 3725bd9f6d2711aa9bb179deea84f51e4424382a. lean/Gnomon/Spec/AxiomsCatalog.lean supplies a motivating RFC, which is a starting lead, not proof that the authored clause covers the whole field. Links below were checked against the current authored Markdown. This table checks specification traceability only; implementation conformance and proof status are separate gates.
Exact authored rule; implementation test mapping pending.
externalIdPermanent (AX-010)
RFC-0036 §3.3: external ID must not be reassigned after deletion
Exact authored rule; implementation test mapping pending.
idSpaceDisjoint (AX-011)
RFC-0036 §3.1: Resource and Statement IDs must not be shared
Exact authored rule; implementation test mapping pending.
statementUniqueness (AX-016)
RFC-0036 §4.2: overlapping intervals on the same triple rejected with M36011
Partial: the formal field says equal S/P/O/validFrom implies equal Statements, including interval edge cases the prose does not spell out. Clarify the authored uniqueness key and test it.
noTripleOverlap (AX-045)
RFC-0036 §4.2: overlapping intervals on the same triple rejected with M36011
Exact authored rule; this shares one authored clause with AX-016. Formal relationship and test mapping pending.
Gap: no exact rule found that identical input and rule produce identical code, severity, and anchor. Add a normative clause and deterministic compiler test.
predicateWriteAndPersist (AX-008)
RFC-0036 §3.4 requires both persisted forms; §4.2 requires exactly one at write time
Exact authored rules; implementation test mapping pending.
softDeleteFilteredWithOverride (AX-014)
RFC-0036 §9.1 requires default filtering and explicit includeSoftDeleted override
Exact authored rule; implementation test mapping pending.
Gap: the cited rule covers one request boundary, not every write, read, validation, and error boundary quantified by the formal field. Define scope or add clauses and tests.
softDeleteObservable (AX-022)
RFC-0036 §9.2 requires projected deletedAt in traversal
Exact authored rule for traversal; check the formal field’s wider read-result scope and implementation tests.
Partial: RFC-0034 is the closer authored clause, but the total accept-or-reject proposition for every Endpoint schema is not stated. Align the catalog citation and add a complete normative rule/test.
Gap: resolvable cross references do not impose a numeric coupling bound.
These are specification traces, not proof or implementation conformance claims. For each partial row, compare the authored rule’s domain and quantifiers with the Lean field and align them. For each gap or conflict, amend the authored and formal contracts together, then add an executable implementation test. Record declaration and assumption dependencies; the proof gate must compile before any row is called proved.