Complete formal consumer diagnostic compilation
Versioned draft snapshot
RFCs, reference catalogs, and evidence reflect Spec 3b2e3e7a114fb826b1445d39a48756b8fff629cd. Counts and pending/status notes belong to that snapshot. Read the dated project update for later progress.
Source repositories are private during staging. Links marked “repository access required” need access to the linked repository.
This is a trace and gap record from the pinned draft specification. It does not establish proof or implementation conformance.
This independently sealed follow-up extends the immutable direct-consumer
stage at spec 90f9bc6d92a4f9d77bd3dc4d95fd0e528e1df93d. It changes no
upstream model, canonical dependency pin, runtime policy, or proof verdict.
The held full consumer candidate is
bcf32923406ea4515b9fe9d0e46a38e7da8ca1ab, parent
9bc57ee2c00ddf1a10c92072080bdbe788e402f2, in the independent
.work/formal-consumer-full-repair-20261013 checkout. Upstream remains
5ba3d99c182b138b4a150deebd6699a386c74286; Lean remains
leanprover/lean4:v4.30.0-rc2 and Mathlib remains
5450b53e5ddc75d46418fabb605edbf36bd0beb6 with the same official cache.
The first stage’s source checkouts, logs, outputs, and byte bindings were not
edited. Its exact import-artifact bindings are inherited and verified here.
Observed full graph
| Stage | Actual complete sources | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Original old-pin baseline | Algebra/Semiring, all 13 area modules, actual umbrella | Native 1 aggregate; 12 areas and umbrella fail; 205 diagnostics |
| First repaired-source candidate | Same graph plus Compat, with only the first stage’s three area repairs | Native 1 aggregate; nine further areas and umbrella fail; 144 diagnostics |
| Full repaired consumer candidate | Algebra/Semiring/Compat, all 13 area modules, actual umbrella | All 17 native calls exit 0; zero errors; 12 explicit sorry warnings |
| Existing generated proof catalog/control | 721 generated entries and existing RFC0036ProofControl | Both native calls exit 0; exactly 718 sorry warnings in generated proofs; zero in control |
The authored graph has 775 declarations, 12 deferred bodies, and zero unassigned code-level sorry tokens. Generated deferrals remain 718; these counts describe separate source streams and must not be summed as unique claims. Native success with these deferred bodies is diagnostic compilation, not proof acceptance. The strict candidate gates retain both counts and the known historical inconsistent-pin blocker.
The existing control checks the conditional write-time XOR implication and equal raw/tag-distinct ID observation against the repaired valid carrier. It does not establish backend conformance or shared bigint allocation exclusion. The generated substage’s first driver created a partial Gnomon output namespace and failed before body checking on missing Compat. That driver and actual native-1 log are preserved. The corrected driver uses the already complete Gnomon output root; no import, schema, or formal source workaround was used.
Bounded source changes
Eight further area files import the existing definitionally equal Compat
aliases. Seven unsupported manifest components are explicitly deferred while
retaining the exact authored project.gnm propositions and other proved
conjuncts. External AX-034 still says project.aion; no branding axiom or
false proof replaces it. The seven additional deferred declarations are:
- BuildInfra
rfc0032_b0_grounded - IO
rfc0030_b34_grounded - LanguageAndTooling
rfc0008_project_manifest_named_project_gnomon - LanguageAndTooling
rfc0017_b11_grounded - LanguageAndTooling
rfc0017_b21_grounded - PostgreSQL
rfc0052_b1_grounded - PostgreSQL
rfc0054_cross_module_ddl_ordering
RuntimeAndHosting and the three first-stage source files are unchanged. 434 further theorem-file hash bindings were refreshed, with seven additional deferred-citation notes. All 722 citations remain reviewed, 715 mismatched; no verdict was promoted. The local delta bundle/patch requires the immutable first-stage consumer tip and is verified.
baseline-source archives ten additional original areas plus the umbrella;
the first stage archives the original other three areas and shared algebra
sources. All original fourteen theorem/umbrella files match spec dff1e21
exactly. The current full candidate is a local review commit, not adopted by
canonical Gnomon or a released dependency artifact.
External and remaining scope
Root reported upstream PR #81 at exact
head 5ba3d99 and CI run 38448196742
completed successfully: ledger, console, registry-consumer smoke, and Bazel
build/test succeeded; the image job was skipped for the PR. This receipt is a
reported root observation, not a fabricated child command log. Native Gnomon
consumer observations above remain a separate scope.
No merge, release tag, registry publication, canonical pin adoption, site refresh, or runtime deployment occurred here. A publicly resolving corrected release artifact, reviewed source pin, remaining 92 upstream assumptions, 715 semantic mismatches, 718 generated/12 authored deferrals, and real backend preservation/diagnostics remain adoption/release obligations. These controls address the two known contradictions and compile actual consumers; they do not certify general framework consistency.
verify.py checks the typed observations, source/output bytes, inherited
dependency bindings, exact counts, and preserved failures without rerunning
builds. Original source snapshots and mail-patch/Git-output whitespace are
retained; authored Markdown/Python/typed evidence use the scoped whitespace
check. The requested honest comment-only source cleanup is a separate
follow-up, preserving this compiled source capsule.