gnomonlearn
Docs/Claim domain identity ownership gaps

Claim domain identity ownership gaps

Versioned draft snapshot

RFCs, reference catalogs, and evidence reflect Spec 3b2e3e7a114fb826b1445d39a48756b8fff629cd. Counts and pending/status notes belong to that snapshot. Read the dated project update for later progress.

Source repositories are private during staging. Links marked “repository access required” need access to the linked repository.

This is a trace and gap record from the pinned draft specification. It does not establish proof or implementation conformance.

Current inventory (2026-10-16)

The canonical generated kg/domain-link-inventory.textproto now records 940 unresolved references to 456 identities across 51 RFCs. RFC-0053 retains 13 references to 13 language-type identities after the approved 58-reference repair. All eleven symbolic dispositions remain unchanged. The actual combined RFC-0053 adoption records the exact changes and current source-bound ledger:

Current review scopeReviewedMatchesMismatches
Complete corpus6,9624,7032,259
RFC-0053 claims785721
RFC-0053 domain nodes582731
RFC-0053 combined1368452

The ordinary ownership inventory passes; its strict release mode remains blocked by those unresolved links. The historical observations and table below retain their counts at their recorded revision.

Historical ownership audit (2026-10-05)

Observed 2026-10-05. Owner: RDF ontology maintainers and individual RFC owners. The new tools/check_claim_domain_links.py checks claimSubject and claimObject references in authored protobuf sources against node definitions across every authored domain source. It excludes external IRIs and unrelated metadata.

Current inventory: 1,105 references to 517 undefined domain IRIs across 52 RFCs. RFC-0053 contributes 71 references to 26 identities, agreeing with its manually inspected identity inventory. This count does not imply that every reference should be renamed: some require an explicit new canonical owner, while others are aliases or have incorrect subjects.

The ordinary command reports gaps; --release fails on them. The normative release gate invokes that strict mode. CI runs the inventory and five tests covering cross-RFC ownership, subject/object references, and excluded external or metadata links. The focused RFC-0053 strict run returned exit 1 as expected. The checker also rejects an empty source corpus, mismatched source metadata, and a selector with no authored claim source. The RFC-9999 selector returned exit 2; an empty corpus and unknown selector have regression coverage.

Acceptance requires owner attribution for every internal identity, explicit source mappings or definitions, regenerated RDF, refreshed reviews, and query consumer validation. Do not make the gate green by treating an incidental object reference or inferred class as an authored definition. Existing reviewed nodes must be revisited where this inventory exposes a previously missed link problem; a source-bound hash verifies currency, not completeness of judgment.

The complete normative release audit remains incomplete and has other known failures. These focused checks do not establish a releasable specification.

Review reconciliation

The ownership audit invalidated 611 earlier whole-node matches across 33 RFCs. Their original text-agreement findings are preserved, with exact unresolved subject/object IRIs appended and verdicts changed to MISMATCHES_SOURCES. No source facts or source hashes changed. Current totals are 5,397 reviewed nodes, 1,957 mismatches, and 1,557 unreviewed nodes out of 6,954. Earlier review documents and site snapshots report counts at their own revisions; this reconciliation supersedes those counts for affected RFCs without proving the text findings wrong.

RFCReviewed matchesReviewed mismatches
RFC-000012121
RFC-000112315
RFC-00028168
RFC-00037554
RFC-00046541
RFC-00057665
RFC-000614151
RFC-00079565
RFC-000818036
RFC-00097050
RFC-001015620
RFC-00116722
RFC-00125043
RFC-0013270
RFC-0014252
RFC-0015310
RFC-0016361
RFC-00175440
RFC-00187562
RFC-00195261
RFC-00206538
RFC-00211810
RFC-00222121
RFC-0023715
RFC-00242224
RFC-00252311
RFC-00266115
RFC-0027180
RFC-00282820
RFC-0029291
RFC-00302614
RFC-00312310
RFC-00321050
RFC-00333012
RFC-00342420
RFC-0035601
RFC-003611258
RFC-00377497
RFC-00387765
RFC-00398557
RFC-004010357
RFC-00415097
RFC-00429913
RFC-00436471
RFC-00445642
RFC-00458234
RFC-00467535
RFC-00473983
RFC-0048745
RFC-0050206
RFC-005113272
RFC-005211440
RFC-00533799
RFC-00548247